An extraordinary exchange unfolded today in a Facebook discussion about the proposed Fraser Battery Energy Storage System in the Town of Hamden, Delaware County, New York.
A local resident with revealing insider knowledge about actions of the Hamden Town Board and Planning Board activities expressed considerable anxiety about the possibility that the DEVELOPER might sue the Town if its Planning Board made "a mistake" in handling the project.
“What happens when we make one wrong move they file a lawsuit and we have no say?” the insider asked.
The insider also warned that public pressure could drive experienced Planning Board members to resign, leaving their replacements vulnerable to procedural mistakes that the developer could exploit.
“As it sits right now there is a law that allows them to do this if we make any mistakes,” the insider wrote, without identifying the law.
I entered the discussion with a simple factual statement: a federal lawsuit concerning the Fraser BESS project had already been filed in the United States District Court for the Northern District of New York on November 2, 2026, and I had notified the Planning Board of that litigation.
The reaction was remarkable.
Rather than asking what the lawsuit challenged, who the defendants were, or what relief was requested, the Town's insider immediately demanded an explanation for its timing:
“but why is it only being filed now when this has been going on for well over a year”
She proceeded to criticize the sudden popularity of OPPOSITION to the project, describing it as “the new cool thing for everyone to focus on.” Yeah... A potential of losing one's property to a catastrophic 🔥 new cool thing, I guess.
There is one particularly revealing aspect of this exchange.
My federal lawsuit is NOT against the Town of Hamden, its Planning Board, or any municipal official. It is against the developers and the parcel owner.
The action seeks judicial protection against the threatened harms associated with the construction and operation of a massive lithium-ion battery storage facility - a catastrophic fire hazard. That is IT.
In other words, my litigation does not present the threat to the Town that the Town insider was warning about.
Unless the Town has deals with the developer the public does not know about already in place.
Which is not at all impossible given that the Town, the County, the nonprofit stakeholders AND the developers are represented by one and same law firm - with a written waiver of this unwaiveable conflict of interest in place.
It is an exercise of a property owner's right - for info of any other Town insiders - to seek judicial relief against industrial hazards threatening diminution of market value and existence of the property.
Yet it is, as the Town insider's somewhat hysterical reaction revealed, the prospect of a hypothetical lawsuit by the developer against the Town that generated considerable anxiety among Planning Board members who are allegedly resigning en masse, while the announcement of an actual lawsuit against the developer generated an indignant demand to explain why it had not been filed earlier.
Well, it was filed duly, and whether members of the Town's Planning Board will or will not be sued by the developer was not within the list of my worries, I must confess.
The exchange also produced some potentially significant information.
The Town insider referred to a Planning Board member's resignation, possible additional resignations, and the prospect of the developer acquiring additional land that could allow it to pursue the project without some of the changes currently under consideration.
Those statements warrant documentary examination.
So, on November 18, 2026, I submitted a FOIL/1st Amendment request to the Town of Hamden seeking records concerning changes to the Fraser BESS site plan, alternative or additional properties under consideration, related communications, and Planning Board resignations.
Unlike speculation about what kind of lawsuits the developer might bring against the Town, these are matters that can be investigated through public records.
The broader question remains: why does the possibility of litigation by a powerful developer command such concern of obvious Town insiders monitoring local social media groups, while actual litigation brought by a property owner to protect her property and challenge the project is greeted with instant aggression?
Access to the courts is not a privilege reserved for developers. It also belongs to property owners - and residents -whose homes, property, and communities are affected by their projects, too.
And, my question to Town and it's insiders in return is - why property owners' rights are being disregarded and discarded in the general fray of things?
PS as of Nov. 19, 2026 based on SOME reader reactions.
A piece of advice - do not try to have me delete my articles unless you have ironclad proof that what I published is false, or wrong, or "misinformation" - as one of the readers tried.
First, nobody cancelled defamation cause of action - I can sue anybody who would claim I am spreading false information without proof that I am doing that. Be very aware of that, I am serious.
But - as a silver lining - to me as a journalist, unsubstantiated attacks is proof I have hit the real nerve.
And I am going to explore it further now.
A follow up article is coming.
No comments:
Post a Comment