Once upon a time, in a kingdom governed by Very Important People, there stood a magnificent castle called The Institution.
The Institution had everything an institution could possibly want: marble stairs, official seals, committees, subcommittees, advisory committees advising the committees, and an impressive collection of documents proving that everything was functioning perfectly.
Whenever villagers complained, a Herald would emerge from the castle gates and announce:
"Nothing is wrong."
The villagers would nod.
After all, the Herald had a very official hat.
Years passed.
One day, a peasant raised a hand.
"But Your Officialness, the bridge collapsed."
The Herald consulted a report.
"The bridge did not collapse."
The peasant pointed.
"It is in the river."
The Herald adjusted his spectacles.
"The bridge is participating in a temporary aquatic relocation initiative."
The villagers looked at one another.
That was odd.
Not enough to cause trouble.
Just odd.
A tiny crack appeared in the Kingdom's Great Reservoir of Trust.
Nobody paid much attention.
Then another bridge relocated itself into a river.
Then a tax collector accidentally taxed three cows, two chickens, and a cabbage for owning an unlicensed boat.
Then a judge declared that a hearing had occurred, despite several participants having never received notice that it existed.
The Herald explained:
"Everything is functioning exactly as intended."
The villagers again looked at one another.
The crack grew.
Now, among the villagers lived a curious old mathematician.
He spent his days drawing equations in the dirt and terrifying local children with discussions of stochastic processes.
The villagers asked him:
"What is happening?"
The mathematician stroked his beard.
"Trust is a funny thing," he said.
"It does not disappear all at once." And he drew this chart.
The villagers were disappointed. They had hoped for a dragon - and
instead they got a lecture.
The mathematician continued.
"Imagine a barrel."
The villagers understood barrels.
"Each strange event adds a drop."
"A drop of what?"
"A drop of doubt."
The villagers nodded. This seemed reasonable.
"Sometimes a good event removes a drop."
"Excellent."
"Sometimes ten bad events add ten drops."
"Less excellent."
"And eventually the barrel overflows."
The villagers became concerned.
"What happens then?"
The mathematician pointed toward the castle.
"Nothing."
"Nothing?"
"Nothing immediately."
The villagers were confused - but the mathematician smiled.
"That is the interesting part."
He explained that people imagine institutional failure as a dramatic event: a revolution! a collapse! a dragon!
Perhaps even two dragons!!
Reality, however, was less theatrical.
The Institution continued issuing reports.
The Herald continued wearing his hat.
The committees continued meeting.
The subcommittees continued discussing the minutes of the previous committee meetings.
Everything looked normal.
Yet something had changed: the villagers no longer interpreted official statements the same way.
Whenever the Herald proclaimed:
"Everything is functioning perfectly,"
the villagers would quietly ask:
"According to whom?"
When a report declared:
"No irregularities have been found,"
the villagers wondered:
"Who looked?"
When an investigation concluded:
"We investigated ourselves and discovered we were correct,"
the villagers developed mysterious facial expressions.
The mathematician called this crossing a threshold.
The villagers called it:
"Having had enough."
Soon the Kingdom entered a strange era.
The castle still possessed authority.
The villagers still obeyed many rules.
Yet the old reservoir of trust had become difficult to refill.
Every new proclamation had to compete with years of accumulated doubt.
The Herald noticed.
The committees noticed.
Even the subcommittees noticed.
This was alarming.
Subcommittees rarely noticed anything.
So the King summoned the mathematician.
"Can trust be restored?" asked the King.
The mathematician considered the question.
"Of course."
The King sighed with relief.
"Excellent. We shall establish a Royal Commission on Trust Restoration."
The mathematician shook his head.
"That is not what I meant."
The King frowned.
"What did you mean?"
The mathematician replied:
"If people lost trust because bridges kept falling into rivers, the solution is not a report explaining that the rivers are at fault."
The King stared.
The mathematician continued.
"If people believe procedures no longer mean what they claim to mean, another proclamation saying the procedures are wonderful will not help."
The King's face became increasingly troubled.
"So what should we do?"
The mathematician pointed toward the nearest collapsed bridge.
"Perhaps begin there."
No comments:
Post a Comment