The final five days of Aliza M. Oliver's life in Delaware
County Jail
According to the federal complaint in Conley v. Delaware
County, Sheriff Craig S. DuMond, et al., No. 9:25-cv-01558-AMN-MJK
(N.D.N.Y.), ECF No. 1, filed November 4, 2025, on October 31, 2024, Aliza M.
Oliver, 22, surrendered to the Schoharie County Sheriff's Office on an
outstanding arrest warrant.
The reason for the surrender - before her incarceration, Ms.
Oliver had pleaded guilty to a B felony drug possession charge in order
to enter the Schoharie County Drug Court program.

According to the federal complaint, she subsequently
relapsed and failed to appear at a scheduled court date, resulting in an
outstanding arrest warrant.
Rather than evade the authorities, after relapsing and
missing a court appearance, she decided to turn herself in, Aliza decided to
surrender.
On October 31, 2024, she contacted her father, Garret C.
Conley, who picked her up and drove her to the Schoharie County Sheriff's
Office.
Neither her father nor Aliza herself knew that the arrest
warrant for failure to appear would quickly turn into Aliza's death
warrant. On November 5, 2024 Aliza was pronounced dead in Delaware County
jail where she was transferred from Schoharie County Jail because Schoharie did
not have a female housing unit.
Delaware County jail had such a unit.
On November 1, 2024, Schoharie County Jail - Schoharie
County Jail — not immediately upon arrival, mind — assessed her medical
condition. That was already a point of medical neglect - the assessment
showed that she needed urgent medical help on arrival the previous day.
The toxicology screen conducted in Schoharie County jail was
positive for benzodiazepines, cocaine, fentanyl, and opiates.
The medical records documented her opioid dependency and anticipated
withdrawal.
Crucially, Schoharie County personnel recognized the danger
of dehydration. They initiated detoxification treatment, provided medication
and fluids, and ordered careful monitoring, including 15-minute checks.
The transferred medical records expressly warned:
“imperative [Aliza] stays hydrated during detox.”
So, the Schoharie County jail, 1 day late
already,
(1) identified the dangers associated with opioid
withdrawal,
(2) initiated detoxification treatment,
(3) provided medication and fluids, and
(4) ordered 15-minute monitoring,
(5) expressly warning that keeping her hydrated was
imperative.
That was the only treatment Aliza received before she died
an unsanitary and torturous death on November 5, 2024 in Delaware County Jail
where no treatment whatsoever was provided to her and the only compassion she
had was from her cellmates.
She was never taken to a hospital while she was still alive.
According to her obituary, Aliza May Oliver-Conley
was born on September 18, 2002, in Niskayuna, New York, to Garret and Brenda
Conley.
She grew up in the Cobleskill area, attended
Cobleskill-Richmondville School, and most recently worked at Wine Shipping in
Cobleskill. She was one of eight children, leaving behind seven
siblings: two brothers and five sisters, as well as several nieces and
nephews.
She was not merely an inmate in Delaware County Jail.
She was not merely a number in jail death statistics.
She was a daughter, a sister to seven siblings, an aunt, and
a young woman whose family was left to mourn her death and to live with the
consequences of her own and her father's decision to entrust the government
with her life in her most vulnerable condition.
Notably, the father drove her not to a hospital, not to a
rehab, while she was in real need of medical help. He drove her to jail -
in the hope that they will help her medically there.
That did not happen.
She pled guilty to a B felony in order to be free through
drug court.
She surrendered herself to authorities in order to follow
the law and obtain help with her drug dependency.
Instead, she was treated worse than a caged animal - and
ended up dead.
Had Schoharie County possessed an appropriate women's
facility, Aliza would not have been transferred to Delaware County Jail, where
the extreme medical neglect amounting to torture - as described in the federal
complaint - cost her life.
She was transferred because Delaware County could house
women. She died on November 5, 2024, because, according to the complaint,
Delaware County failed to provide the medical care necessary to keep her alive.
This is what the federal complaint alleges as to HOW she
died.
October 31–November 1, 2024: Aliza voluntarily surrenders
and enters custody
This is the available booking photo of the girl whose life
Delco jailers irresponsibly and cruelly squandered.
Aliza Oliver's November 1, 2024 Delco booking picture in
DelCo jail.

Aliza Oliver's November 5, 2024 funeral pictures.


Because Schoharie County lacked a women's housing unit,
Aliza was transferred to the Delaware County Correctional Facility that
evening, accompanied by her medical records.
PLEASE NOTE - Schoharie County, even though it is not sued,
SHOULD BE - they did not transfer the girl TO THE HOSPITAL which she badly
needed - they transferred her to another jail, in the evening, when the main
medical personnel was mainly unavaialable.
I KNOW Delaware County Jail - as a criminal defense attorney
in the past, I received regular complaints of inmates that medical help there
has been, for years, UNAVAILABLE, and denied deliberately and with
disdain. It was a routine occurrence that when hospitalization was
needed, it was denied by the jail nurse.
So it happened in Schoharie. So it happened in
Delaware. Rendering a 22-year-old woman, a member of a large family -
PREVENTABLY dead.
According to the complaint, close before midnight on
November 1, 2024, a registered nurse Bethany Brinkerhoff assessed her.
Aliza was identified as having opioid use disorder
and signed a request to participate in the jail's medication-assisted
treatment program.
She was assigned to Housing Unit D, Cell 7, a specialized
medical housing unit requiring increased supervision.
Let's retrace possibilities for medical help for Aliza
Oliver.
The closest hospital to Richmondville, New York, where,
according to her obituary, Aliza Oliver lived at the time of her surrender on
October 31, 2024 to the Schoharie County Sheriff, was Cobleskill
Regional Hospital, part of the Bassett Healthcare Network.
Address of hospital: 178 Grandview Dr, Cobleskill, NY
12043, United States
Distance: Approximately 5–7 miles from
Richmondville, depending on the starting point and route.

Estimated driving time: 10–15 minutes.
There is an ER department there, (518) 254-3337,
open 24 hours a day, seven days a week.
She lived in Richmondville, NY.
Instead of driving to that nearby hospital, a 7 to 10 minute
drive, she asked her father to drive her to the Schoharie County Jail located
at

Here is what Google gives as information from the center of Richmondville,
New York, to 157 Steadman Way, Howes Cave, NY 12092 (Schoharie
County Sheriff's Office and Correctional Facility):
- Estimated
driving distance: 13–15 miles (21–24 km).
- Estimated
driving time: 20–25 minutes.
- Straight-line
distance: Approximately 10 miles.

While being in a medical emergency, both Aliza and her
father - a father of 8 children - trusted the system enough to go not to a
nearby ER, but to a father jail facility, abiding by the law and in the hope of
Aliza getting help.
Now - what did Schoharie County Jail did - after evaluating
Aliza as needing urgent medical help:
Did it transfer her to a nearby hospital?

Nah.
It kept her overnight - without availability of a female
housing unit I can only imagine where that was and in what condition Aliza,
already undergoing a medical emergency, spent that night.
It then transferred her the next day - to the
hospital?
Nah.
To Delaware County jail located in Delhi, NY, at 280
Phoebe Lane.
The distance?
55–65 miles through the mountainous terrain of the northern
Catskills, depending on the route taken - through Oneonta, NY or through Exit
20 off I-88 - taking an estimated 70–85 minutes by car.
Regardless of the choice of route selected, each route -
PERSONAL experience, I drove those roads on a daily basis in any weather, day
and night, for 16 years - it would be, after exit off I-88, a winding,
two-lane mountain road with double solid yellow lines prohibiting passing in
either direction.
Consider the physical experience of that journey for a young
woman already undergoing medically supervised opioid withdrawal, with hydration
identified by Schoharie County medical personnel as imperative. For
approximately an hour and a half, Aliza M. Oliver was transported in a moving
vehicle across the mountainous terrain separating Schoharie and Delaware
Counties.
If the transporting officers followed the usual security
procedures for moving incarcerated individuals, she may also have been
restrained by handcuffs and leg shackles, limiting her ability to reposition
herself, brace against sudden movements, or respond naturally to nausea.
For at least 40–50 minutes of the necessary route off I-88,
the vehicle would travel through the northern Catskills' rolling and
mountainous landscape, where the highway follows changing elevations and curves
around the terrain.
Imagine traveling at highway speed along a winding mountain
road where the vehicle is constantly moving in three dimensions at once. First,
the road climbs steeply, then suddenly drops, pitching the vehicle forward and
backward, making your stomach rise and fall as though on a roller coaster. At
the same time, the road itself tilts from one side to the other, so that the
vehicle rocks sideways like a seesaw, first leaning toward the driver's side,
then toward the passenger's side. And while all this is happening, the
highway twists through sharp left and right curves, pushing your body sideways
against the seat, the door, or the seat belt. These movements overlap:
the vehicle may be climbing, leaning to one side, and turning sharply at the
same time, then immediately descend, tilt the other way, and swing into another
curve. Your body is being pushed, pulled, lifted, dropped, and rocked
from side to side, with little opportunity to recover between movements.
Now add the surrounding landscape. On one side of the road,
a steep, glacier-carved mountainside rises above the highway; on the other, the
ground falls away into a deep ravine. As the vehicle rounds a curve, the
passenger may see the mountainside looming ahead, then suddenly find herself
looking down a steep drop beyond the edge of the pavement. The road seems to
twist between rock walls and open precipices, sometimes climbing toward a blind
crest, sometimes plunging into a valley with the next turn hidden from view.
Even for a healthy passenger, especially one unfamiliar with mountain driving,
the combination of rapid three-dimensional movement and the sight of steep
drop-offs can be frightening and nauseating. For someone already undergoing
opioid withdrawal, physically weak, possibly dehydrated, and potentially
restrained by handcuffs and leg shackles, an hour and a half of such travel
could be an intensely distressing physical experience, with motion-induced
nausea, abdominal discomfort, dizziness, fear, and the inability to reposition
or brace herself freely against the vehicle's movements.
For someone experiencing opioid withdrawal, the combined
sensations can be particularly distressing. Withdrawal commonly produces
nausea, abdominal cramping, sweating, dizziness, and heightened sensitivity to
physical discomfort. Repeated changes in direction and acceleration stimulate
the vestibular system, while the visual perception of rapidly approaching
curves, rising roadways, and descending valleys can intensify motion-induced
nausea. A patient who is already nauseated may experience additional retching
or vomiting. If handcuffed or shackled, she may have difficulty leaning
forward, stabilizing herself, reaching for a receptacle, or adjusting her
position to relieve abdominal discomfort. Every episode of vomiting can further
deplete fluids and electrolytes, particularly when adequate hydration is
unavailable.
Nor would the discomfort necessarily cease between curves.
Highway vibration passes continuously through the vehicle's suspension and
seat. Expansion joints, uneven pavement, changes in road grade, and the
vehicle's normal pitching and rolling movements add smaller, repeated
disturbances. A patient experiencing abdominal cramps and nausea may have
little opportunity to settle physically before the next turn, rise, descent, or
braking maneuver. For a restrained passenger, the experience can be one of being
repeatedly moved by forces over which she has no control, unable to assume the
positions that might make the journey more tolerable.
The cumulative effect matters. This was not simply a
question of transporting Aliza from one correctional facility to another. It
was a prolonged journey involving a patient whose medical records already
identified a need for supervised withdrawal treatment and careful attention to
hydration. The combination of travel duration, possible physical restraints,
potential lack of drinking water, highway-speed motion, and repeated changes in
direction and elevation created foreseeable risks of aggravating nausea and
vomiting. Whether Aliza actually experienced those effects during the transfer
requires evidence concerning her symptoms, the vehicle, its speed and route,
the restraints used, and the care provided en route. The physical demands of
such a journey nevertheless make the absence or adequacy of medical monitoring
and transport precautions a significant question.
There is another consideration. Aliza M. Oliver lived in
Richmondville, New York, a community in the Schoharie Valley, surrounded by
rolling hills and agricultural countryside. Although Richmondville itself lies
in a mountainous region, living there does not necessarily mean being
accustomed to prolonged highway travel through the more dramatic mountain
terrain farther south. We do not know whether Aliza had previously traveled the
route between Schoharie and Delaware Counties or experienced this particular
combination of steep climbs and descents, sideways road tilting, sharp curves,
and deep ravines. She may have been encountering it for the first time.
And experiencing such a drive for the first time is not for
the faint of heart, even in perfect health. Imagine sitting in a vehicle moving
at highway speed while the road rises and plunges, tips from side to side like
a seesaw, and simultaneously twists through sharp curves. On one side, a
glacier-carved mountainside rises steeply above the road; on the other, the
ground drops away into a ravine. The passenger sees the mountainside looming
ahead, then suddenly a steep drop beside the vehicle, while her body is being
pushed sideways, pitched forward and backward, and lifted and lowered by the
changing road surface. The movements occur together, not one at a time. Even an
experienced passenger may find the combination frightening and nauseating,
particularly when the next curve or descent is concealed by the terrain.
Now imagine encountering those conditions while undergoing
opioid withdrawal, already medically vulnerable, with hydration identified by
medical personnel as imperative. Add the possibility of handcuffs and leg
shackles restricting movement, the uncertainty of whether drinking water was
available, and approximately an hour and a half of travel. A person unfamiliar
with such roads might experience not only motion sickness but considerable
fear, intensified by the inability to control the vehicle, anticipate its
movements, or freely adjust her position. Nausea, abdominal cramps, dizziness,
and physical weakness could make every climb, descent, sideways tilt, and
sudden turn more difficult to endure. For Aliza, whose condition already
required medical supervision and careful attention to hydration, this was
potentially much more than an uncomfortable drive. It was a physically
demanding journey capable of aggravating the very symptoms that medical personnel
were supposed to monitor and treat.
She was repeatedly, by two facilities, transferred back and
forth, over miles and miles of complex terrain instead of seeking immediate
medical help, available without any such trips. Locally, close to where
she lived.
The circumstances of Aliza's transfer are particularly
troubling because, according to the federal complaint in Conley v. Delaware
County, No. 9:25-cv-01558-AMN-MJK, ECF No. 1, Schoharie County medical
personnel had already identified her opioid dependency, initiated a
detoxification protocol, and expressly documented that maintaining her
hydration during withdrawal was imperative. Yet, instead of remaining at the
originating facility, approximately 6–8 miles from Cobleskill Regional Hospital
and its emergency department, Aliza was transported to another county jail more
than an hour away. The medical questions raised by that decision include
whether she was evaluated for fitness to travel, whether her withdrawal
symptoms and hydration status were assessed immediately before departure,
whether medical monitoring or treatment was available during transport, and
whether transporting personnel received instructions concerning deterioration
or the need for emergency hospitalization.
The New York State Sheriffs' Association's own Corrections
Accreditation Manual, revised October 2026, addresses precisely these
concerns.
Standard 113, at page 130, requires written
procedures for consultation between correctional administrators and responsible
medical professionals concerning institutional transfers involving patients
with significant medical conditions.
Its commentary specifically identifies suitability for
travel based on medical evaluation, preparation of pertinent medical records,
medication or other treatment required during transport, and instructions to
transporting personnel as matters to be considered.
Standard 163, at page 192, separately addresses
continuity of medical care when incarcerated patients are transferred between
correctional facilities, including the transmission of medical records, current
treatment information, and anticipated health-care needs.
These provisions demonstrate that the accrediting
association itself recognizes interfacility transfers as medical events
requiring planning and continuity of care, not merely transportation
arrangements.
The contrast is striking. Schoharie County Jail was
located a relatively short drive from an emergency hospital. Delaware County
Jail was more than an hour away, across rural mountainous terrain. Aliza
arrived at the receiving jail with a documented need for medically supervised
withdrawal treatment and adequate hydration. According to the complaint,
Delaware County personnel failed to continue the treatment and monitoring
initiated by Schoharie County, and over the following days she developed
persistent vomiting, diarrhea, profound weakness, and ultimately fatal
hypernatremic dehydration.
What the record already raises is the question of why a
medically vulnerable 22-year-old woman was transported between county jails
over a substantial distance, and how the receiving facility handled the
documented medical needs that accompanied her. (Conley, ECF No. 1,
¶¶42–56, 57–95, 184; NYSSA, Corrections Accreditation Manual, October
2026 revision, Standards 113 and 163, pp. 130, 192.)
Delhi, NY, the town where Delaware County Jail is located at
280 Phoebe Lane, and where Aliza was taken from the Schoharie County jail on
November 1, 2024, is a small town - but is also the county seat.
As such, it has its own hospital - The O'Connor Hospital, at
460 Andes Road.

I lived - and raised young children - in Delhi, NY for 16
years, from 1999 to 2015.
I most certainly know its medical facilities, and used them
when needed for my family.
As a criminal defense attorney in the past, I also visited
Delaware County jail - often - and know where it is located.
I have NOTHING BAD to say about this hospital. It
helped me and my family numerous times. It could help Aliza Oliver.
Had she been given a chance. Had she not been caged and barred from
medical care.
The distance from the jail to the hospital is a 7-minutes’
drive!!!!! That 7 minute's drive, a difference between life and death,
was denied her by Delaware County Sheriff's office and its personnel.

The hospital has an ER - and a helicopter pad to airlift
emergency cases the hospital cannot handle to the Albany Medical Center.
Now, according
to Johns Hopkins Medicine, opioid withdrawal, although extremely
distressing, is rarely life-threatening. Withdrawal symptoms, including
nausea, vomiting, abdominal cramping, sweating, and other physical
manifestations, typically intensify over approximately 72 hours before
beginning to subside. With appropriate medical management, including
hydration, monitoring, and medication, patients can ordinarily survive
withdrawal without life-threatening complications.
Aliza M. Oliver did not die simply because she was
withdrawing from opioids. She died from a recognizable and treatable
complication of prolonged, inadequately treated withdrawal: severe
hypernatremic dehydration. (Johns Hopkins Medicine, Opioid Use Disorder,
section “Opioid Withdrawal Treatment (Detoxification)”; Conley v. Delaware
County, No. 9:25-cv-01558-AMN-MJK, ECF No. 1, ¶184.)
The danger was identified before Aliza even arrived at
Delaware County Jail. On November 1, 2024, Schoharie County medical
personnel assessed her condition, initiated detoxification treatment, provided
medication and fluids, and expressly documented that maintaining hydration was
imperative. Those records accompanied her transfer to Delaware County
Jail that evening. Nevertheless, according to the federal complaint, Delaware
County personnel failed to continue the prescribed treatment and monitoring.
Over the following days, Aliza experienced persistent vomiting and diarrhea,
becoming progressively unable to retain fluids, food, or oral medication. Her
continued loss of water caused severe dehydration and hypernatremia, a
potentially fatal elevation of blood sodium concentration. (Conley, ECF
No. 1, ¶¶42–73, 184.)
By November 3, 2024, Aliza was vomiting dark brown material
resembling coffee grounds, suffering profound weakness, and repeatedly
requesting hospitalization. Instead of transferring her to an emergency
department for assessment and intravenous rehydration, jail medical personnel
continued attempting oral treatment despite knowing that she could not retain
liquids. Nurse practitioner Gregg Kujawski, who never personally examined
Aliza, after being consulted by phone, ordered repeated three-hour periods
without oral intake whenever vomiting continued. And no IV
fluids.
So, while the woman was dying from dehydration, a registered
nurse ordered to further withdraw fluids from her orally - and no IV
fluids. Very logical. Top level of medical care.
According to the complaint, because the vomiting never
stopped, those instructions resulted in repeated withholding of fluids from
a patient already experiencing dangerous fluid losses. No hospital
transfer or intravenous rehydration was ordered. (Conley, ECF No. 1,
¶¶74–110.). Aliza was not taken to O'Connor. A 911 call to
get O'Connor's ambulance was not made.
On November 4, 2024, Aliza was collapsing, unable to stand
without support, and eventually crawling because she was too weak to
walk.
That evening, she explicitly requested hospitalization
and intravenous fluids. She was still alive, she was lucid enough to
understand she needed hospital-level help, and she affirmatively asked for it.
The hospital help was one 911 call away. It was a 7
minutes' drive away.
She was denied it.
Registered nurse Bethany Brinkerhoff documented both her
request and her warning: “if I die its [sic] on you.” Yet, rather
than arranging emergency treatment and IV fluids, Brinkerhoff advised
Aliza to drink water or Gatorade slowly and returned her to her
cell.
By the following morning, Aliza was repeatedly unresponsive.
At approximately 1:25 p.m. on November 5, 2024, medical
personnel finally entered her cell and found her face down, with fixed,
dilated pupils, cyanotic nailbeds, and no detectable pedal pulse. She was
pronounced dead at 2:07 p.m. (Conley, ECF No. 1, ¶¶111–185.)
The autopsy, as reported in the federal complaint,
attributed Aliza's death to complications of hypernatremic dehydration
resulting from days of vomiting and diarrhea. The medical distinction
is fundamental: opioid withdrawal is rarely fatal, but severe dehydration
resulting from persistent vomiting and diarrhea can cause circulatory
collapse, neurological injury, coma, and death.
Aliza's fatal complication was neither sudden nor
unanticipated.
The risk had been expressly identified by Schoharie County
medical personnel on November 1, 2024; her deterioration was documented
repeatedly by Delaware County personnel; and Aliza herself specifically
requested the intravenous fluids she needed.
According to her father's complaint, Delaware County Jail
allowed a treatable medical emergency to progress over several days until the
22-year-old woman died in its custody. (Conley, ECF No. 1, ¶¶42–197.)
While she was still alive, she asked for help, and asked
repeatedly.
According to the federal complaint, by November 2, 2024, Aliza
was suffering from persistent vomiting and diarrhea.
She completed an Alcohol and Drug Abuse Services Referral
Form asking:
“I was just wondering if there is anything I can get
to help with withdrawals from heroine/fentayl [sic] and Benzos”
She did not DEMAND medical help that she was ENTITLED to -
she humbly was "wondering if there [was] anything [she could] get to help
with withdrawals".
The complaint states that she had received no
withdrawal medication, fluids, or appropriate treatment at Delaware County
Jail before that request.
A fellow inmate who knew Aliza outside jail reported that Aliza
looked so sick she was almost unrecognizable. Her lips were dry
and cracked. She complained of thirst. That DID NOT get
attention of Delco Jail personnel, including medical personnel, in the special
medical unit - despite of transfer medical documents from the Schoharie County
jail.
It was an inmate who helped Aliza call her parents so
they could purchase drinks for her through the commissary
(!!!!!!!!!). Instead of fluids she was entitled to receive from her
jailers as part of medical treatment - but was denied.
The inmate also warned her parents that Aliza was seriously
ill and expressed fear that she was not receiving enough fluids.
By this point, Aliza was too weak to clean up after
herself.
Her cell became contaminated with vomit and diarrhea.
Imagine WHAT THAT MEANS.
According to the complaint, after being denied medical care
- which caused continuing vomiting and diarrhea - she was denied even the very
basic right to a clean cell.
According to the complaint, correctional officers refused to
clean the cell.
Only after neighboring inmates complained about
the smell were other incarcerated women permitted to clean Aliza's
cell. Not the jail personnel. Other inmates. No
hospitalization even then.
And, the vomiting and diarrhea continued.
At approximately 10:00 p.m., nurse Rosemary Balcom
examined Aliza after correctional officers reported multiple vomiting
episodes. Aliza told Balcom that she had been vomiting and
suffering from diarrhea throughout the day.
Balcom contacted Kujawski, who finally ordered the
initiation of a detoxification protocol—24 hours or more after Aliza
arrived.
Throughout November 2,2024 Aliza repeatedly asked to be
taken to a hospital.
According to the complaint, every request was ignored.
Complaint ¶¶ 57–73, at 11–13.
She could be alive today had that 911 call been made.
I wonder - I REALLY REALLY wonder - whether the Delaware
County Attorney was in the know on all of this while Aliza was dying - and
directed withdrawing the medical care to save the County money for
hospitalization. I hope discovery in the case will bring light to this -
because this type of information is not FOILable. For privacy - of the
woman KILLED by Delco.
According to the complaint, by November 3, 2024, the
symptoms had progressed, according to the 8:00 a.m. note by
nurse Balcom, to Aliza's continued vomiting, inability to eat breakfast,
and continued diarrhea.
Aliza described herself as:
“weak + wobbly”
She was having difficulty walking to the medication cart.
Balcom telephoned Kujawski, who ordered Gatorade at
each medication pass. No IV fluids still, no 911 call and no 7-minutes’ drive
or ride to the O'Connor Hospital.
At 2:00 p.m., Balcom documented continuing nausea,
vomiting, and physical weakness.
Documented.
Like with a lab animal.
The complaint observes that her records did not document
providing the Gatorade or seeking further medical consultation at that time.
Meanwhile, neighboring inmates reported that Aliza's cell
was covered with material resembling blood and coffee grounds.
Coffee-ground emesis is a recognized warning sign of a
potentially life-threatening medical emergency requiring prompt evaluation in a
hospital emergency department. The term describes vomit containing
dark, granular material resembling wet coffee grounds, which can result when
blood from the upper gastrointestinal tract reacts with stomach acid. It
may indicate bleeding from the esophagus, stomach, or duodenum, including
hemorrhage caused by tears resulting from repeated forceful vomiting. Its
appearance warrants urgent medical assessment to determine the source
and severity of possible bleeding.
In Aliza M. Oliver's case, the warning signs were
particularly grave: by November 3, 2024, neighboring inmates reported blood and
coffee-ground-like material in her cell, while nurse Rosemary Balcom documented (again,
like for a lab animal, without providing any help) brown liquid on the floor
following episodes of projectile vomiting.
By November 4, Aliza's vomit had reportedly turned black and
smelled like feces. These symptoms occurred alongside days of persistent
vomiting and diarrhea, inability to retain fluids, progressive weakness, and
repeated requests for hospitalization. The combination of suspected
gastrointestinal bleeding, severe dehydration, and deteriorating consciousness
constituted a medical emergency demanding immediate intervention, not continued
routine management of opioid withdrawal.
Yet, according to the federal complaint, jail medical
personnel neither arranged emergency hospital evaluation nor even attempted
to transfer Aliza to the jail infirmary.
Aliza M. Oliver, age 22, died on November 5, 2024, from
complications of hypernatremic dehydration, as reported in the autopsy
findings.
The complaint does not identify gastrointestinal hemorrhage
as a confirmed cause of death, but it documents warning signs of a potentially
life-threatening condition that demanded urgent medical attention well before
Aliza's fatal collapse. (Conley v. Delaware County, No.
9:25-cv-01558-AMN-MJK, ECF No. 1, ¶¶79–95, 111–139, 184.)
Also, consider that the coroner is the County officer - and
that the autopsy could be botched to help the County out in the predictable
future lawsuit.
*
* *
NOW. While the wrongful death federal lawsuit
regarding the above-described death of 22-year-old Aliza M. Oliver in Delaware
County jail is ongoing, enter the November 10, 2026 celebration of the
absolute, supreme preeminence of that same Delaware County jail in recognition
of its superb "best practices".
The Best Practices of Delaware County Jail — According to
the NY Sheriffs' Accrediting Association
On November 10, 2026, The Reporter announced that the
Delaware County Sheriff's Office had received renewed accreditation for its
jail.
New York State Sheriffs' Association Executive Director
Peter R. Kehoe congratulated Sheriff Craig DuMond and his correctional staff,
explaining that the jail had undergone an outside assessment against 166
standards and best practices.
According to The Reporter (a newspaper belonging to
brother of one of on and off - now on-against Delaware County officers) - the
assessors found that Delaware County Jail met, and in most cases exceeded,
those standards.
Met! And exceeded!
Let us examine a few of those magnificent best practices
against the allegations in the pending federal wrongful-death action, Conley
v. Delaware County, No. 9:25-cv-01558-AMN-MJK (N.D.N.Y.), ECF No. 1, filed
November 4, 2025.
The New
York State Sheriffs' Association's own Corrections Accreditation Manual,
revised October 2026, is particularly helpful in that assessment.
BEST PRACTICE NO. 1: RECOGNIZING MEDICAL EMERGENCIES.
Standard 125, at page 142, requires health-related
training of correctional personnel in recognizing life-threatening
emergencies, intoxication, withdrawal, and the need for appropriate medical
referral. The manual explains that correctional officers are the eyes and
ears of medical staff and must recognize symptoms and report what they observe.
Really?
According to the Conley complaint, by November 3, 2024,
Aliza Oliver had been vomiting and suffering diarrhea for days.
Neighboring inmates reported material resembling blood and coffee grounds in
her cell. Nurse Rosemary Balcom documented brown liquid on the floor
following projectile vomiting. By November 4, Aliza was collapsing,
unable to walk, and crawling across the floor.
Yet, it was the neighoring inmates - and not COs and not
medical personnel - who (1) reported medical emergencies, reported the SMELL of
VOMIT and FECES on the floor that COs left uncleaned, and then arranged for
INMATE cleaning of potentially biologically hazardous matter, exposing other
INMATES to danger and COUNTY to liability. It was the inmates who helped
Aliza call her parents to arrange for SOME hydration - so that the parents
would PAY through COMMISSARY to give her SOME of the hydration she was
repeatedly denied by the jail personnel.
Her fellow inmates recognized the emergency. The trained
correctional personnel, according to the complaint, continued treating her
condition as misbehavior.
BEST PRACTICE NO. 2: TWENTY-FOUR-HOUR EMERGENCY MEDICAL
CARE.
Standard 146, at page 171, requires a written plan for
24-hour emergency medical care, including emergency vehicles, designated
hospital emergency departments, and procedures for immediate transfer when
necessary. The manual defines emergency care as treatment for acute
illness that cannot wait for the next routine medical appointment.
Really?
Aliza repeatedly requested hospitalization. On
November 4, 2024, she specifically requested intravenous fluids and warned
nurse Bethany Brinkerhoff that she might die. According to the complaint,
she received advice to drink water or Gatorade slowly and was returned to her
cell.
O'Connor Hospital, with its emergency department, was
located in Delhi, the same village as the jail, a 7-minutes’ drive. Delco
jailers did not even have to DRIVE her there - all they had to do is to use
their brains to get to their phones and use their dainty fingers to tap three
buttons - 9, then 1 and then 1 again. And the ambulance would have COME.
FAST.
Yet Aliza was not transported there during the days when she
was still conscious and begging for treatment, nor were those 3 buttons
tapped.
Emergency medical services were summoned only after she
became unresponsive and was found in cardiac arrest on November 5, 2024.
BEST PRACTICE NO. 3: SPECIALIZED CARE FOR DRUG
WITHDRAWAL.
Standard 152 of the New York State Sheriffs'
Association's Corrections Accreditation Manual, revised October 2026,
pages 178–179, specifically governs the treatment of incarcerated individuals
undergoing withdrawal from alcohol or other drugs. It requires written
policies, procedures, and specific clinical protocols approved by the
responsible medical or mental health professional, together with compliance
with New York State Commission of Correction health-services standards.
The commentary expressly recognizes that withdrawal from
alcohol, sedatives, and opioids can produce serious complications when not
properly identified and managed. It explains that withdrawal
management must begin with appropriate screening and assessment upon
admission, followed by continuing clinical monitoring to detect
changes in the patient's condition. It acknowledges that early
identification is critical because withdrawal can progress rapidly and, in
severe cases, cause seizures, delirium, or death. The manual specifically
identifies patients with complicated withdrawal histories or coexisting medical
conditions as requiring particular attention, specialized protocols, and closer
monitoring.
The manual further explains that detoxification is a
clinically supervised process involving supportive medical care and, where
appropriate, medication. It acknowledges that treatment protocols must
reflect current medical standards and be individualized according to the
patient's risk factors and actual clinical presentation. It provides that
patients experiencing mild or moderate withdrawal may be managed in a
correctional facility only when adequate staffing, clinical supervision, and
timely medical intervention are available. It further acknowledges
that severe withdrawal syndromes must not be managed in a nonhospital
setting, and patients requiring monitoring or treatment beyond the facility's
capabilities must be transferred without delay. The manual repeats
this transfer requirement on page 179.
Really?
According to the federal complaint in Conley v. Delaware
County, No. 9:25-cv-01558-AMN-MJK, ECF No. 1, Schoharie County medical
personnel had already identified Aliza M. Oliver's withdrawal risks, initiated
detoxification treatment, provided medication and fluids, and expressly warned
that maintaining hydration was imperative before transferring her to Delaware
County Jail on November 1, 2024.
Delaware County received those medical records but allegedly
failed to continue the prescribed treatment and monitoring.
Over the following days, Aliza suffered persistent vomiting
and diarrhea, became unable to retain fluids or oral medication, developed
profound weakness, collapsed repeatedly, and ultimately became unable to
walk. She was made to crawl on the floor of her cell in her own vomit,
feces and eventually - regurgitated blood mixed with feces, with no help, even
with cleanup.
Nurse practitioner Gregg Kujawski, who never personally
examined her, continued directing treatment by telephone, including repeated
periods without oral intake despite her ongoing vomiting. Aliza
repeatedly requested hospitalization and, on November 4, 2024, specifically
asked for intravenous fluids. No hospital transfer was ordered. She died
on November 5, 2024, from complications of hypernatremic dehydration, as
reported in the autopsy findings. The very medical deterioration
that Standard 152 instructs correctional facilities to identify, monitor,
treat, and refer for higher-level care was documented over several days in the
jail whose compliance with professional best practices was celebrated on
November 10, 2026. (Conley, ECF No. 1, ¶¶42–185; NYSSA, Corrections
Accreditation Manual, October 2026 revision, Standard 152, pp. 178–179.)
And, that happened after Schoharie County medical personnel
had already assessed Aliza, initiated detoxification treatment, and expressly
warned that hydration was imperative. Those records accompanied her transfer to
Delaware County Jail on November 1, 2024.
According to the complaint, Delaware County did not continue
the treatment and monitoring initiated by Schoharie County. Nurse practitioner
Gregg Kujawski made treatment decisions by telephone without personally
examining Aliza. As she continued vomiting, he ordered repeated periods without
oral intake. She received neither intravenous rehydration nor hospital
treatment.
On November 5, 2024, Aliza died from complications of
hypernatremic dehydration, according to the autopsy findings reported in the
complaint.
BEST PRACTICE NO. 4: ACTING ON INMATES' REQUESTS FOR
MEDICAL ASSISTANCE.
Standard 140, at page 164, requires that inmates' requests
for medical assistance be documented, reviewed by qualified health personnel,
and followed by appropriate triage and treatment.
And NYS Sheriff's Association found that Delco Jail (now?)
meets and exceeds this standard?
Really?
Aliza requested help with withdrawal on November 2. She
repeatedly asked to be taken to a hospital. On November 4, she explicitly
requested intravenous fluids.
Her warning to nurse Brinkerhoff was preserved in the
medical record:
“if I die its [sic] on you”
She died the following afternoon.
The issue is not whether the jail possessed a mechanism for
receiving medical requests. It is what happened after those requests were
received. As in: NOTHING happened other than TORTURE and DEATH.
BEST PRACTICE NO. 5: PROFESSIONAL, DIGNIFIED MEDICAL
TREATMENT.
Standard 142 of the New York State Sheriffs'
Association's Corrections Accreditation Manual, revised October 2026,
page 167, specifically addresses the privacy, dignity, and treatment of
incarcerated patients during medical encounters. It requires written
policies providing that medical encounters be conducted privately, with
a chaperone when indicated, and, most importantly, in a manner designed to
encourage patients to continue seeking medical services.
The accompanying commentary expressly states: “Health care
should be provided with consideration of the patient's dignity and feelings.”
It illustrates this requirement by specifying that verbal consent should be
obtained before rectal or pelvic examinations. Thus, the standard
addresses more than physical privacy. It requires an approach to medical
treatment that respects the patient's dignity and encourages continued
communication with medical personnel, rather than discouraging patients from
reporting symptoms or requesting assistance (NYSSA, Corrections
Accreditation Manual, October 2026 revision, Standard 142, p. 167).
And, Delco Jail meets and exceeds this standard - that's
what the celebratory accreditation article was about.
Really?
PRIVACY. According to the federal complaint,
Aliza spent her final days in a cell contaminated with vomit, diarrhea, urine,
and feces, while neighboring inmates witnessed and reported her progressive
deterioration. She became so weak that she could no longer clean herself
or her surroundings. Other inmates complained about the conditions,
attempted to help clean her cell, and repeatedly alerted correctional officers
to her condition. Her most intimate bodily functions, physical helplessness,
and medical suffering became matters of observation and discussion throughout
the housing unit, rather than being addressed through appropriate medical care
in a clinical setting. Despite the availability of a jail infirmary, and
nearby hospital, Aliza was never transferred there for treatment despite her
repeated requests while she was still lucid and conscious. (Conley v.
Delaware County, No. 9:25-cv-01558-AMN-MJK, ECF No. 1, ¶¶79–139.)
DIGNITY. By November 4, 2024, Aliza was
repeatedly collapsing, unable to stand or walk without assistance, and
eventually crawling across the floor. According to the complaint, head
nurse Ira Fyfe treated her apparent loss of consciousness as pretense
and flicked water onto the dying woman's face - dying from that same
nurse's medical neglect.
On November 5, 2024, the day of Aliza M. Oliver's death,
Corporal Joanne Yager reportedly kicked Aliza's cell door and shouted
at her to stop being dramatic while she lay face down and failed to respond.
A critically ill young woman, unable to control her bodily functions or even
stand, was treated as someone pretending to be sick rather than as a patient
experiencing a medical emergency. This is the treatment to compare with
the accrediting association's express requirement that medical care respect the
patient's dignity and feelings. (Conley, ECF No. 1, ¶¶111–185; NYSSA, Corrections
Accreditation Manual, October 2026 revision, Standard 142, p. 167.)
ENCOURAGING PATIENTS TO CONTINUE SEEKING MEDICAL
ASSISTANCE. Aliza did exactly what a patient was supposed to do: she
repeatedly reported her symptoms, requested medical attention, asked to be
transported to a hospital, and, on November 4, specifically requested
intravenous fluids. She even warned nurse Bethany Brinkerhoff, “if I
die its [sic] on you.” Instead of arranging emergency
hospitalization, Brinkerhoff advised her to drink water or Gatorade slowly -
with that same Gatorade, nor IV fluids which were required by the situation,
NOT PROVIDED by the jail, despite documented dehydration, including visual
symptoms such as dried cracked lips. Brinkerhoff then returned the
dying young woman to her cell - not hospital, not jail infirmary - without any
help.
According to the complaint, other jail personnel continued
dismissing her worsening condition as exaggeration or pretense.
Aliza continued seeking help until she became physically incapable of
doing so.
On November 5, 2024, the very day when Corporal Joanne Yager
reportedly kicked Aliza's cell door and shouted at her to stop being
dramatic while she lay face down and failed to respond - she was
pronounced dead at 2:07 p.m.
In our XXIst goddammit century! Like a caged animal,
among her own feces, vomit and blood mixed with feces with vomit.
Forgotten and mocked by the very people charged with her medical care.
Standard 142 - that Delco Jail is being celebrated by The
Reporter as having met and exceeded - requires medical encounters
designed to encourage patients to continue seeking care.
The Conley complaint describes a patient who repeatedly
sought care, was met with disbelief and humiliation, and ultimately died
without receiving the emergency hospital treatment she requested. (Conley,
ECF No. 1, ¶¶111–185; NYSSA, Corrections Accreditation Manual, October
2026 revision, Standard 142, p. 167.)
There is more.
On November 4, 2024, the day before Aliza M. Oliver's death,
according to the complaint, head nurse Ira Fyfe treated Aliza's apparent
loss of consciousness as pretense, recording that she was
pretending to be unresponsive and flicking water onto her face.
Instead of tapping those goddammit three buttons - 9 and 1 and 1 again!
By then, Aliza could barely stand.
And on November 5, 2024 - yes, I repeat it again - and again
- and again - this girl is younger than my youngest of three children - when
Aliza lay face down and failed to respond, neighboring inmates reportedly heard
Corporal Joanne Yager kicking her cell door and shouting at Aliza to stop being
dramatic.
The young girl, with the entire life in front of her was
dying - from these evil animals' neglect of their very basic duties that they
are now shamelessly celebrating of "meeting and exceeding." And
then - dead.
BEST PRACTICE NO. 6: ACCURATE RECORDS AND ACCOUNTABILITY.
Standard 67, at page 77 of the New York State
Sheriffs' Association's Corrections Accreditation Manual, revised
October 2026, requires the correctional division to maintain a
records-management system incorporating review of reports for completeness and
accuracy, control of reports through indexing, routing, and follow-up, secure
maintenance and retrieval of records, and procedures for responding to requests
under New York's Freedom of Information Law. The standard expressly
requires documentary proof of these components.
Standard 69, at page 79, requires an
administrative reporting program providing for daily, monthly, and annual
inmate records of correctional division activities, together with periodic
statistical and data summaries. Its commentary specifically identifies daily
forms, log sheets, and computer-generated reports as records that must satisfy
the requirements of oversight agencies and the facility's operational
needs. It further specifies that these records must be adequate
for responding to FOIL requests and for evaluating institutional goals and
preparing budgets.
While I will certainly be checking out whether Delco Jail's
procedure are FOIL-friendly as its newly-renewed accreditation requires, and
will report the results on this blog, the accrediting association does not
merely require jail personnel to write something in a log. It requires a
system in which reports are reviewed for accuracy and completeness,
properly maintained, and available for administrative and oversight purposes
(NYSSA, Corrections Accreditation Manual, October 2026 revision,
Standards 67 and 69, pp. 77, 79).
And the celebratory article in The Reporter claims that
Delco Jail meets and exceeds THOSE standards.
Really?
According to the federal complaint in Conley v. Delaware
County, No. 9:25-cv-01558-AMN-MJK, ECF No. 1, the observation records
maintained by Delaware County Jail repeatedly described Aliza M. Oliver as “ok”
during the final hours of her life, notwithstanding her progressive
deterioration, inability to walk, repeated episodes of apparent
unconsciousness, and eventual complete unresponsiveness.
On November 5, 2024, correctional officers continued
entering reassuring observations while Aliza was lying on the floor of her cell.
As a trained litigator, I can see all the signs of preparing
for a wrongful death action - to hide, misrepresent and destroy evidence - that
is what these animals were doing while Aliza was dying. That she was
dying - and dying from lack of medical care - was obvious, based on the
reports, even to a lay person.
At 11:25 a.m. on the day of Aliza's DEATH, Corporal Joanne
Yager reportedly recorded that Aliza had refused lunch.
Yet, according to neighboring inmates whose accounts are
described in the complaint, Aliza was lying face down and failing to respond
when officers attempted to communicate with her.
A person who is unconscious cannot meaningfully refuse
lunch.
She was UNABLE TO EAT, goddammit. And these animals
STILL undertook NO STEPS to save her - while they still could.
Recording an unresponsive inmate as having refused food
transforms an observable medical emergency into an apparently voluntary
decision by the inmate.
The significance of these entries extends beyond poor
recordkeeping. The complaint describes repeated so-called discrepancies
between the jail's written observations and the physical condition of Aliza
documented through witness accounts, medical records, and investigative
evidence. Those discrepancies concern precisely the information that
correctional observation logs are intended to preserve: whether the person in
custody was conscious, responsive, physically capable of movement, and in need
of immediate medical attention.
Under Standard 67, the question is not simply whether
officers completed the required entries. Who reviewed those reports for
accuracy and completeness? Who examined the repeated “ok” notations
against the contemporaneous medical records describing vomiting, diarrhea,
collapse, and apparent loss of consciousness? Who reviewed the entry
describing a supposed refusal of lunch against the accounts of an inmate lying
face down and unresponsive?
Under Standard 69, the corresponding question is what the
jail's administrative reporting system did with those records. Were the
observation logs reviewed as part of the facility's daily inmate reporting?
Were the discrepancies identified, investigated, or referred to supervisory
personnel? Were the records made available to the accreditation
assessors, and did those assessors examine the underlying observations rather
than merely verify that the required forms had been completed?
The New York State Sheriffs' Association congratulated
Delaware County Jail on November 10, 2026, for meeting and largely exceeding
its professional standards. The Conley complaint, meanwhile, describes a
jail whose records repeatedly represented a dying young woman as “ok.”
THE BASTARDS!!!!!!
And - reportedly by a witness - this is not the first such death in that jail, several of them happened there over more or less recent years, and some money manipulation took place. More for appropriate authorities to explore.