My husband and I have been sued for what is called an "easement dispute".
For the second time.
The first identical case has been dismissed in December last year for lack of jurisdiction, but without prejudice, so the lawsuit was re-filed.
The lawsuit is litigated electronically, through e-filing in NYSCEF.
The gist of the story a corporation by the name of Berrian Inc. claims that it owns a commercial building at 85 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753 (home of the so-called Stewart's Mercantile Store") located next to our building at 83 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753.
The corporation wants us to remove a fence on the property separating the parking lot at 83 Main Street, Delhi, NY 13753 and the Village of Delhi parking lot, so that their commercial vehicles can (1) park, for free, in OUR parking lot, and (2) drive through OUR parking lot from the Village of Delhi parking lot through to Main Street and back.
We object.
The driving force of litigation is Stephanie Halberian, well known in Delhi, NY as owner of the so-called Blue Bee Cafe, and her attorney Gerard N. Misk, of Ginsburg & Misk, LLP.
Coincidentally, Ginsburg & Misk, LLP are also attorneys for two individuals who, represented by the same Ginsburg & Misk, LLP during the 1st action have provided Stephanie Halberian a $210,000 mortgage with a pledge of personal guarantee of her own and her husband's assets, all of them, to the two private lenders (Attorney Misk's personal friends out of New Jersey, owners of retail stores and gas stations).
The mortgage was to buy 114 Main Street, Delhi, NY for the Blue Bee Cafe.
The mortgage is available online from the Delaware County Clerk's Office public records register, under Beacon Records, Inc., since the name Blue Bee Cafe is a DBA (doing business as) of Beacon Records, Inc.
I will not go into the merits of the lawsuit against us by Berrian Inc., as we are not at a pre-merits stage of the case, discussing jurisdiction of the court.
You can download, for free, no registration needed, any filings from either of the lawsuits, 1st or 2nd, if you type in Google
"NYSCEF guest search" and then click on the link that appears in the search and enter my name into the menu, then two cases will appear, click on either one of them, depending on what you want to see.
Berrian Inc. v. Neroni, EF2023-322 is the dismissed case.
Berrian Inc. v. Neroni, EF2023-943 is the currently pending case.
The currently presiding judge has reserved his decision on our motions to dismiss and put some issues up for an evidentiary hearing, a sort of a mini-trial with witnesses and cross-examination.
The hearing is currently scheduled for Monday, May 13, 2024, at 1:30 A.M., on the Internet, through Microsoft Teams.
Members of the public may attend the hearing.
To do that, they need to send a request to the court system providing their e-mail address (where the link to enter the virtual meeting will be sent).
Click on this link,
Or, enter in your browser the full path of the link:
https://portal.nycourts.gov/knowledgebase/article/KA-01070/en-us
At the bottom of the page that opens, click the blue words "Virtual Appearance Viewing Request Link".
In the form that opens, enter the following:
For Contact Information - enter your e-mail, confirm it, and enter nothing else.
For County, choose Delaware in the drop-down list on the left - and another drop-down menu, Court, will appear on the right.
For Court, check the only box there, Delaware County Supreme Court multibench, hit Select below.
In the right, for Date, choose 6/6/2024, 6/7/2024 - two separate days, two separate applications.
For Other Information, Case Number put in
EF2023-943
For Case Caption put in
Berrian, Inc. v. Neroni
You are done, hit the Submit button below.
You will soon receive an e-mail confirmation from the court system that your request is received and is being processed, and you will later receive an e-mail from the court giving you a link how to enter the Microsoft Teams meeting (you do not need to download anything to enter, as far as I know), and an entry code.
The New York Court system prohibits the screen recording, video recording and audio recording of court proceedings.
If anybody wants me to fill out their virtual requests to attend, they can send their preferred e-mail addresses to me through comments for this article, messenger, or email tatiana.neroni@gmail.com. I will try to forward to the court system all requests sent to me.
If you are interested in how a real court hearing works, whether you are a non-lawyer member of the public, or a law student, you are very much encouraged to attend, it may be ... lively and interesting.
Issues that the court has put up for the hearing are:
(1) whether service of process upon my husband and myself was proper;
(2) whether notarizations on Plaintiff's affidavits of service were defective.
The hearing is set up for 3 hours on June 6, 2024, from 1 pm Eastern time to 4 pm Eastern time, and for 6.5 hours (just in case) for June 7, 2024, from 1 pm Eastern time to 7 30 pm Eastern time, even though it can be shorter or longer, nobody can tell ahead of time.
No comments:
Post a Comment